T4America Blog

News, press releases and other updates

A closer look at Rep. DeFazio’s bid to replace the gas tax with an oil fee

With the Highway Trust Fund rushing toward insolvency, Rep. Peter DeFazio (D-OR) this week stepped up by proposing a policy to address this issue by replacing the gasoline pump tax with a per-barrel oil fee and indexation of the diesel tax that together is sufficient to keep the federal program solvent.

The “Repeal and Rebuild Act” would create a per-barrel fee on oil headed to refineries, with a refund for non-automotive uses and diesel fuel. Although consumers would no longer pay directly, Rep. DeFazio’s office says, this would preserve the “user pays” feature of the highway and transit program by continuing to collect based on fuel use.

“What if we got rid of the tax that people don’t like,” Rep. De Fazio told The Oregonian newspaper, “and move it upstream to something that most people don’t like — the oil industry?”

A barrel tax of $6.75, combined with indexing the diesel tax to rise with inflation, would raise $314 billion over 10 years, Rep. DeFazio’s office says. The proposal includes repeal of the current truck tire excise tax. The barrel fee would rise over time, because it would be “double indexed” to match the growth of the U.S. DOT’s Highway Construction Cost Index and to replace revenue lost as CAFE standards require greater fuel efficiency. Together with indexing the diesel fuel tax, DeFazio’s proposal would raise $104 billion more over ten years than continuing the existing gas tax.

But the changes would not help with the near-term shortfall, Rep. DeFazio acknowledges. The first year would actually raise less than the current gas tax, providing some short-term relief to consumers and oil companies. In fact, it will take until 2017 before we start seeing any positive revenue from this bill.

To cover the short-term gap, Rep. DeFazio would bond $89 billion against future receipts, repaying it over 10 years with the additional $104 billion raised under his proposal.

The gas tax that currently stands at 18.4 cents per gallon and the diesel tax that currently stands at 24.4 cents per gallon funds our country’s transportation system. The gas tax has remained at that rate since 1993 and has since lost nearly 40 percent of its purchasing power because of inflation. As costs have risen, revenue has dropped as vehicles grow more efficient and an increasingly urbanized population drives fewer miles per person. Congress has had to transfer more than $50 billion from the general fund to the transportation fund since 2008 stave off insolvency.

A skeptic might wonder whether it will make a difference to consumers if oil companies simply pass the cost on down the line to the pump. But Defazio believes the oil companies might actually end up taking some of the fees from their profits. “Why are they [the oil companies] fighting so hard against it if they could pass on every penny of it?” he asked.

Rep. DeFazio’s proposal has merit, being as it is an all-too-rare effort to address the longterm solvency of the transportation’s trust and our ability to maintain and build a 21st century network. While it takes courage to lead on raising transportation revenue, recent experience indicates voters may be tolerant of the notion. In two states were revenues have been raised recently, Virginia and Pennsylvania,  more than 95 percent of legislators were returned to office after voting for a gas tax increase (more here).

We commend Rep. DeFazio and look forward to his peers joining him to pass the “Repeal and Rebuild Act”.

To read about other current proposals from both sides of the aisle, you can click on our recap here. There is also a summary of the differences between the House and the Senate legislation here.


  1. Pingback: What Else Could Cities Do With the Space Devoted to Cars? | Streetsblog.net

  2. Pingback: The Case for Taxing Oil Before It Reaches the Pump | Streetsblog.net

  3. Don Puckett

    10 years ago

    Just a reminder of how we were forced into the 2008 Bankster ditch, and why we’re still in it. Thank God for people like Wyden, Merkley, and DeFazio, or we’d be in over our heads in goop, or are we..

    You can’t blame Bush all together for higher and higher fuel prices, but he did add his sweaty on it by not putting a collar & leach on Cheney in 2001 during his closed door secret meeting (still secret today) with the oil industry. The big boiling kettle of corruption goes to both the republicans & democrat’s new Corporate Congress. Then there was Bill Clinton (the guy that took credit for the .Dot-Com fiasco), who as he was packing up to leave the Oval Toilet for good sign the demise of the Glass Steagall Act. You know the law enacted in 1933 to keep another Great Depression from ever happening again.The law that kept Banksters from using Citizens savings, and insurance premiums to speculate in very risky stock investments. But even before Clinton signed the death of the Glass Steagall Act. Citi Bank and Travelers Insurance were attempting to merge, to become an investment bank CitiGroup, the very thing that the Glass Steagall Act was designed to stop from ever happening again. Together CitiBank & Travelers throw $16 million (in those days big money, now it’s just chump change) into lobbying congress into killing the GSA. The minute Bill killed the GSA the rapping and pillaging of America began with renewed earnest. Seven years later the economy did a 1929 repeat, and the only thing that stop America from going over the edge again was the bright idea of bailing the Banksters out of a ditch that it took them eight years to dig, and another eight years of back filling …… with truck loads of more of corporate & congressional hooliganism. Don’t believe it. Watch Bill Moyer’s interview with former CEO of Citi Bank John Reed, who admits, tearfully, now that the demise of the Glass Steagall Act was a big mistake, his shame for being involved, and the damage that was done to America’s middle class.

    http://billmoyers.com/segment/john-reed-on-big-banks-power-and-influence/ You have got to watch this if you haven’t already.