Repair Priorities: Ranking state spending
Policymakers continue to emphasize “fix-it-first,” but the data tell a different story. Our analysis in Repair Priorities shows only marginal improvement in road conditions, leaving the costly backlog of roads in poor condition largely unchanged.

To illustrate the relationship between states’ spending choices and road conditions, we grouped states into a framework based on their investment priorities and resulting pavement outcomes.
States are categorized based on the following key metrics:
- Good spending ratio refers to the top half of states based on their ratio of maintenance to expansion spending. These 25 states exceed $2.35 dollars spent on maintenance for every $1.00 spent on expansion. (2018-2024 annual average).
- Bad spending ratio refers to the bottom half of states based on their ratio of maintenance to expansion spending. These 25 states spend less than $2.35 dollars on maintenance for every $1.00 spent on expansion. (2018-2024 annual average).
- Best repair conditions refers to the top half of states with a share of federal-aid roadways in poor condition in 2024 that is lower than the national average of 16.3%
- Bad repair conditions refers to the bottom half of states with a share of federal-aid roadways in poor condition in 2024 that is higher than the national average of 16.3%.
This framework highlights how spending priorities and road conditions interact, revealing which states are prioritizing maintenance to keep systems in a good state of repair, which are catching up, and which will likely fall further behind.
Good spending, best repair conditions
Delaware, Idaho, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nebraska, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Vermont, Wyoming
States such as North and South Dakota, Minnesota, and Vermont demonstrate a clear alignment between investment strategy and system performance. By continuing to prioritize repair, they have maintained a higher share of roads in good condition and avoided major maintenance backlogs. In many cases, these states either shifted toward repair early or maintained steady investment over time. Their experience shows that sustained, repair-focused spending can preserve system quality more efficiently.
Good spending, bad repair conditions
Alaska, California, Colorado, Illinois, Maryland, Michigan, Missouri, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island
States in this category, including California, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Missouri, and Rhode Island, illustrate the difficulty of reversing decline once it has taken hold. While these states now direct a majority of funding toward repair, many are managing aging infrastructure or longstanding backlogs. For example, California has an extensive, heavily traveled system with deterioration that accumulated over time and will require billions to improve. These states may be on an upward trajectory, but progress will likely be gradual and require sustained investment to catch up.
Bad spending, best repair conditions
Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Montana, Nevada, North Carolina, Oregon, Tennessee
States including North Carolina, Georgia, Oregon, and Florida maintain relatively strong roadway conditions despite allocating a smaller share of funding to repair versus expansion compared to other states. In many cases, this reflects newer infrastructure and recent, rapid system expansion (such as in North Carolina) that has not yet required significant upkeep. Adding a new mile of freshly paved road increases the miles of roads in good condition—but only until those assets begin to deteriorate. If these states continue to underinvest in repair, they are likely to follow the path of other states that have declining conditions and growing maintenance backlogs.
Bad spending, bad repair conditions
Arizona, Connecticut, Hawaii, Louisiana, Mississippi, South Carolina, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin
States such as Arizona, Texas, Utah, Hawaii, Washington, and West Virginia exemplify the consequences of prioritizing expansion over repair. Some of these states, like Arizona, South Carolina, Utah, and Texas, have seen significant sustained growth in recent years and have made major investments to expand highway capacity. Almost half of these states spent more on expansion than on repair between 2018 and 2024—Utah spent just 33 cents on road maintenance for every dollar spent on road expansion, and Washington spent just 24 cents on maintenance for every dollar spent expanding roads. Because so much of their systems are relatively new, states like Utah, South Carolina, and Virginia do not break the bottom 10 list for roads in poor condition, but with continued underinvestment in repair, they may soon do so.
However, other states like Louisiana, Mississippi, Wisconsin, and West Virginia, where growth has been negative or slow relative to other states, have high ratios of funds spent on expansion versus maintenance. This trend runs counter to these states’ need to fix their below-average road conditions. Importantly, these states continue to allocate a smaller share of funding toward repair, meaning they remain on a trajectory that risks further declines in system conditions and escalating long-term costs. Their experience underscores how delaying maintenance and failing to realign spending priorities leads to persistently poor outcomes.